ADVERTISEMENT
The events of January 31, 2026, began with the deceptive normalcy of a family dinner. Nancy had spent the evening with her daughter, Annie Guthrie, and Tommaso Cioni. Following the meal, Cioni acted as the escort, driving Nancy back to her home in the Catalina Foothills—an upscale, serene neighborhood known for its quiet streets and panoramic views of the Tucson landscape. Cioni reported to investigators that he dropped Nancy off at approximately 9:45 p.m. and, following a standard safety protocol, remained in his vehicle until he saw her cross the threshold and close the front door. This was the last time a family member would confirm seeing Nancy Guthrie. When she failed to attend her usual Sunday morning church service the next day and stopped responding to calls, the silence from her home became an immediate signal of distress.+1
